sticky-yellowConclusions
Cause of Death: Carbon monoxide poisoning.
Mechanism of Death: Lack of oxygen (hypoxia) from breathing in car exhaust.
Manner of Death: Accidental.
Marcel most likely turned on his car while working in the closed garage and was overcome by the fumes before he could escape.
sticky-yellowThis scene suggested poisoning rather than blunt trauma or firearm injury. The presence of caffeine in the coffee and the absence of external injuries pointed toward ingestion of a toxic compound, possibly introduced into a beverage.
imageThis is where the bat is
imageImage description
imageImage description
imageImage description
sticky-yellowThe organocarbamide concentration (30 mg/L) is well above the lethal threshold, confirming it as the primary toxic agent.
The presence of caffeine (65 mg/L) indicates significant stimulant ingestion, possibly from coffee used as the vehicle for poisoning.
Acetaminophen levels were within therapeutic range and likely incidental.
imageBlood typing case the type of blood that was at the scnce
sticky-yellowJenn Newgard
Cam Banks
Kay Litrell
Aiden Santori
Naomi Lee
imageJenn Newgard
Cam Banks
Kay Litrell
Aiden Santori
Naomi Lee
imageImage description
sticky-yellowMarcel Newgard was a 23-year-old college student and restaurant worker who was found dead in his garage on a hot Sunday afternoon. His manager called the police for a well-being check after Marcel didn’t show up for work two days in a row, which was unusual for him. When officers arrived, they found Marcel lying face down on the garage floor. After examining the scene and collecting evidence, investigators learned that he died from accidental carbon monoxide poisoning caused by his car running inside the closed garage.
sticky-yellowEvidence What It Showed
Body temperature and lividity Body heat matched the garage temperature; lividity on the front showed he stayed face down since death.
No rigor mortis Rigor had already passed, meaning he had been dead for more than a day.
Insect evidence Blue bottle fly larvae were in the second stage, showing he’d been dead for about 1–2 days.
Car in garage Key in ignition and gas almost empty meant the car had been running, producing carbon monoxide.
Toxicology report High levels of carbon monoxide in his blood proved poisoning from car exhaust.
Phone data No activity after Saturday morning, matching the estimated time of death.
All the evidence fits the conclusion that Marcel accidentally poisoned himself by breathing car exhaust.
Unimportant (Presumptive) Evidence
Evidence Why It Wasn’t Important
Tools and toolbox Normal for a garage; no signs of struggle or foul play.
Energy drink can Contained caffeine only; not related to his death.
Small bruise on arm Happened when he fell; didn’t cause death.
Unlocked door Common for his home; nothing stolen or disturbed.
sticky-yellowDate/Time Event
Friday evening Marcel came home after classes and told friends he was working on a school project in his garage.
Saturday morning His phone stopped showing any new activity after 9:45 a.m. He missed his Saturday night shift at the restaurant.
Sunday, 1:30 p.m. Marcel’s boss, Naomi Lee, called the police to ask for a welfare check.
Sunday, 2:00 p.m. Police arrived and found Marcel dead in his garage.
Sunday, 2:30 p.m. The medical examiner arrived. The body temperature was 93 °F, lividity was fixed on the front, there was no rigor mortis, and green coloring had started. Blue bottle fly larvae (second instar) were found on the face.
Estimated Time of Death: Sometime Friday night or early Saturday morning (about 24–36 hours before discovery).
sticky-yellowThe garage door was closed, and Marcel’s car was inside with the keys in the ignition and the gas tank almost empty. The body was near the driver’s side, face down, with no signs of injury or struggle. The air in the garage was very hot (93 °F). Nothing looked disturbed or stolen.
All of this suggested that Marcel had been in the garage with the car running and accidentally breathed in too much carbon monoxide. He probably lost consciousness quickly and died without realizing what was happening.